Stocks

Underwriter Relationship Disruptions Cut VC IPO Exits and Fund Multiples

Nov 02, 2026 • 5 min read • views

Venture capital firms’ access to public markets appears to depend partly on who they know at investment banks. A study by Tuft and Yimfor, published in the Review of Finance in 2026, finds that losing established underwriter relationships is associated with fewer IPO exits and lower fund multiples. The results put financial intermediary networks alongside company selection and operating support as a potential contributor to venture capital performance.

The estimated effects are material: disruptions to VC-underwriter ties reduce IPO exits by about 9.5% and fund multiples by about 7.8%. The authors identify the relationship between the two outcomes by examining underwriter mergers and closures, which can break existing connections for reasons external to a venture capital firm’s portfolio. Their analysis compares firms affected by these disruptions with firms whose underwriting relationships remain intact.

Why a bank connection can matter

Taking a company public requires more than a promising business and receptive investors. Young companies often have short operating histories, uncertain earnings prospects and substantial intangible assets. Those features can make their value harder for outside investors to assess. Underwriters help companies navigate the IPO process, and established working relationships may give venture capital firms a more effective route through that process.

The study’s findings suggest those ties do more than provide access to a familiar financial institution. Repeated dealings can build trust, improve the flow of information and give bankers knowledge of a VC firm and its portfolio. That accumulated familiarity may help parties handle the work involved in preparing and marketing an offering. When a connection is disrupted, a firm may need to rebuild that understanding with another underwriter at a time when portfolio companies are seeking an exit.

Underwriters may also become involved before a company is ready for an IPO. The authors report that they act as deal facilitators or late-stage investors in roughly 15% of cases. That involvement points to a broader role for intermediary networks: they can shape how companies progress from private financing toward a potential public listing, not simply determine which bank leads an offering.

The relationship may rest with individuals

A notable result concerns what makes these connections valuable. The authors find that disruptions tied to underwriter mergers are more damaging when employee turnover is high. That pattern suggests relationship value can be concentrated in individual bankers, whose experience and familiarity with a VC firm may not automatically transfer when institutions combine.

An institution’s name and market standing may open doors, but people carry much of the working knowledge built through repeated interactions. If experienced bankers leave, a venture capital firm can lose contacts as well as accumulated understanding of how to work together. The authors consider other explanations, including underwriter specialization and industry expertise, but conclude that these factors do not fully account for the results. Their evidence instead points to relationship-specific human capital as an important part of public market access.

That distinction matters when assessing the durability of a relationship. A bank merger doesn’t necessarily erase every connection, and a change in personnel doesn’t guarantee that an IPO will fail. The study estimates average effects across the disruptions it examines. Still, the results indicate that ties can be vulnerable when the people who maintain them depart or move to other roles.

Smaller firms face a tighter margin for disruption

The impact is more pronounced for smaller venture capital firms and funds nearing the point when they need to exit investments. Larger, established firms may have broader networks, stronger reputations and more potential underwriters to call on. Smaller firms may have fewer alternatives and may find it harder to establish credibility with a new bank. A lost connection can therefore take longer to replace.

Fund timing adds another constraint. A fund approaching the end of its life has less room to wait while its manager develops a new underwriting relationship. If an IPO is delayed or becomes harder to execute, the fund’s options for realizing value can narrow. The findings therefore connect intermediary ties not only to the likelihood of public listings but also to the timing and realization of venture capital returns.

For people evaluating private market managers, the study broadens the set of factors that may help explain performance. A track record reflects outcomes, but it may not show how dependent a manager is on a small set of financial intermediaries or on particular bankers. The research suggests that network depth, IPO execution experience and continuity among key contacts can be relevant to understanding how a manager converts portfolio company progress into exits.

What the evidence can and can’t establish

The authors use underwriter mergers and closures as sources of disruption and apply a difference-in-differences approach. This design lets them compare changes in IPO exits and fund multiples for affected VC firms against changes for firms that retain their relationships. The approach is intended to isolate the consequences of losing established ties, rather than simply compare firms that have many connections with firms that have few.

The estimates are averages from the events and firms studied; they aren’t forecasts for a particular fund or portfolio company. The results also don’t imply that all IPO exits rely on one underwriter relationship, or that replacing a bank is impossible. They show that, in the authors’ analysis, disrupted ties have measurable consequences even when the underlying venture capital firm and its investments remain part of the comparison.

The paper’s chart examines whether shared personnel history is associated with joint IPO activity. It compares the number of senior partners at a VC firm who previously worked at a given underwriter with the number of startups backed by that VC firm whose IPOs the underwriter handled. The graph groups the personnel overlap into four bins and shows 95% confidence intervals around the averages.

The results are hypothetical results and are NOT an indicator of future results and do NOT represent returns that any investor actually attained. Indexes are unmanaged and do not reflect management or trading fees, and one cannot invest directly in an index.

Implications for venture capital performance

Venture returns are often discussed in terms of selecting companies and helping them grow. This research adds another link in the chain: a firm’s ability to work with intermediaries that help portfolio companies reach public markets. That capability may be especially consequential for smaller managers and funds closer to their exit period, when replacing a disrupted relationship can be difficult and delays have less time to be absorbed.

The practical takeaway is that intermediary ties are part of the infrastructure behind an IPO exit. Their value may depend on the stability of the people who maintain them, the alternatives available to a VC firm and the fund’s timing. For managers and those assessing them, the study suggests that network quality is best understood as a working capability—with relationships that can survive institutional change—rather than as a list of bank names.

Research and source

  • Tuft and Yimfor
  • Review of Finance, 2026
  • A version of the paper can be found here
  • More academic finance paper summaries are available in the Academic Research Insight category.

The authors’ abstract describes the paper as causal evidence on relationships among financial intermediaries. It reports that losing established ties between venture capital firms and investment bank underwriters, due to underwriter mergers and closures, reduces VC IPO exits by 9.5% and fund multiples by 7.8%.

Financial Intermediary Relationships and Public Market Access was originally published at Alpha Architect. Please read the Alpha Architect disclosures at your convenience.

Source: Elisabetta Basilico, PhD, CFA · alphaarchitect.com