Banking

Nine Years of Public Law Library Work Could Determine $40,000 in Student Loan Forgiveness

Oct 28, 2026 • 5 min read • views
Female librarian looking book at the shelf in law library.

Why Nine Years of Work Are at the Center of This Case

The dispute turns on a basic question: does Public Service Loan Forgiveness depend on the borrower’s employer or on the specific work they do? Melissa Scheeren says the Department of Education has denied her credit for nine years at a public law library, even though the government’s own records and statements appear to support her account. That mismatch is more consequential than a routine paperwork error. It could determine whether her loans should already have been forgiven.

Scheeren worked full-time at the Fairfax Bar Association’s public law library and pro bono center from March 2008 through February 2017. She later worked for Arlington County, the Library of Congress and the University of Virginia, all government employers. By her count, she reached 120 qualifying payments in June 2019 if the bar association years are included. The Department of Education (ED) currently credits her with 81 qualifying payments.

She consolidated older FFEL loans into a Direct Consolidation Loan on November 4, 2021, under the Biden Limited PSLF Waiver. ED later credited 210 eligible payments to the new loan, but only 81 count as qualifying. The department has not credited her Fairfax Bar Association employment.

In May 2026, Scheeren sued ED and MOHELA (PDF File), arguing that she was entitled to Public Service Loan Forgiveness when she applied in September 2022. She says she has paid $16,140.71 on loans that should have been discharged, with about $40,000 still outstanding. She wants the court to overturn the denials and require ED to process the forgiveness.

The organization’s tax status is part of the dispute. A 501(c)(3) nonprofit generally qualifies as a PSLF employer automatically. Other nonprofits, including the Fairfax Bar Association, a 501(c)(6), must meet a public-service test. The Justice Department agrees that Scheeren’s employment met that test, yet the issue appears to have delayed her application.

The Application Record Shows Years of Unresolved Questions

Scheeren filed three PSLF applications. ED and MOHELA denied two, giving different reasons, and have never decided the third. She also pursued reconsideration, filed a complaint with ED and escalated the matter to an ombudsman, following the steps borrowers are told to take.

One Borrower’s PSLF Record 2008–2026
DateWhat HappenedOutcome
Mar. 2008–Feb. 2017Works full-time at the Fairfax Bar Association’s public law library and pro bono center108 PaymentsMade during these years, by her count. ED counts none of them.
Apr. 2018–PresentWorks full-time for government employers: Arlington County, the Library of Congress and the University of Virginia81 PaymentsCredited by ED as of July 2026
June 2019Reaches her 120th qualifying payment, by her count120 PaymentsEligible for forgiveness if the bar association years count
Nov. 4, 2021Consolidates older FFEL loans into a Direct Consolidation Loan during the Limited PSLF Waiver210 EligibleED later credits 210 eligible payments on the new loan
Sept. 2, 2022Files PSLF Application 1 with the association’s bylawsDeniedOct. 24, 2022, calling the nonprofit “a for-profit organization”
Oct. 24, 2022Files PSLF Application 2 with bylaws and public website materialsDeniedOct. 27, 2023, saying it “does not provide a public service”
Dec. 12, 2022Files PSLF Application 3, adding articles of incorporation and a letter from the executive directorNever DecidedStill open
July 13, 2023Files Reconsideration Request 1DeniedFive days later
Nov. 13, 2023Files Reconsideration Request 2 with certified corporate recordsDeniedMarch 27, 2024, with the same one-line reason
Jan. 30, 2024Files a complaint with the Department of EducationClosedFeb. 27, 2025, with a general form letter
May 13, 2026Sues ED and MOHELA in federal courtPendingBefore Judge Christopher Cooper
Where She Stands81 qualifying payments credited, 189 if the bar association years count120 needed for forgiveness
Source: Scheeren v. Department of Education court filings. The College Investor.

The timeline makes the gap hard to miss: ED credits 81 payments from her government employment, while Scheeren says the 108 payments during her bar association years should also count. The table’s total says 189 qualifying payments if those years are accepted, above the 120 required for forgiveness. The record also shows ED credited 210 eligible payments after consolidation, a different measure from the 81 qualifying payments.

MOHELA served as ED’s dedicated PSLF servicer from July 2022 to July 2024. In its July 2026 answer (PDF File), MOHELA denied making the decision to reject Scheeren’s application. The company also faces an AFT lawsuit over its PSLF processing.

The Government’s Argument Conflicts With Its Own Explanation

The central legal question is whether PSLF evaluates the borrower’s duties or the employer’s eligibility. The Justice Department’s August 19, 2026 motion for summary judgment (PDF File) says Scheeren “was required to prove that most of her employment with the FBA was in one of the enumerated fields.”

That reading is difficult to square with the program’s stated approach. PSLF generally asks whether someone works full-time for a qualifying employer, not whether their individual job duties are public service. That’s why workers in different roles at a qualifying employer can pursue forgiveness. In a letter to Sen. Tim Kaine (PDF File) filed as one of DOJ’s exhibits, Federal Student Aid said eligibility “is not about the work a borrower does but is based on who their employer is.” That matches how PSLF has worked since 2008.

There’s a timing issue, too. DOJ relies on a provision in ED’s 2022 final rule (PDF File), which took effect July 1, 2023, after Scheeren applied. The earlier rule covered private nonprofits providing a listed service, including public library services. Those service categories still determine which nonprofit employers qualify for PSLF.

The later rule’s majority test concerns the employer: a qualifying organization must devote a majority of its full-time staff to eligible work. The rulemaking also says eligibility has always depended on “whether the borrower works for a qualifying employer, not their specific job.” ED tried to narrow employer eligibility again in 2025, but a federal judge struck down that rule in June 2026.

Even the filings appear to accept key facts. DOJ’s brief acknowledges that the bar association is a nonprofit. ED declarant Nikki Harris Bowman wrote in her declaration (PDF File) that operating a public law library “meets the criteria” of the regulation. The brief describes the denial as resting on “an incorrect finding,” yet still argues that the denial should stand.

Scheeren’s lawyer, Austin Hinkle of Public Goods Practice, called Bowman’s declaration an after-the-fact rationale in a September 9 opposition and cross-motion (PDF File). On LinkedIn, Hinkle wrote that ED “apparently just made up some new interpretation of a decades old law for this case.” He also says DOJ’s reply “conceded that it was entirely wrong about the law” while continuing to ask the court to rule in its favor. The reply is sealed, however, and The College Investor says it has not reviewed it.

What Other Nonprofit Employees Should Take From This

A nonprofit that isn’t a 501(c)(3), such as a bar association, may still qualify as a PSLF employer. Under the current rule, it must devote a majority of its full-time staff to a listed public service, and it can’t be a labor union or partisan political group. The test applies to the employer, so a librarian and an accountant at the same qualifying organization can earn PSLF credit on the same basis.

If ED rejects your employer, its letter to Sen. Kaine says reconsideration isn’t the remedy. The guidance is to submit a new PSLF form through the PSLF Help Tool and upload supporting records, such as bylaws. Keep copies of every form and denial letter. Scheeren’s saved documents became the administrative record ED certified in court.

A Case Playing Out Amid Broader PSLF Delays

ED’s efforts to restrict which employers qualify for PSLF have faced legal setbacks. The department appealed rulings against its 2025 employer rule in August, then dropped those appeals in October.

Borrowers also face a technical problem: a system glitch has kept them from seeing their most current qualifying payment counts since July 2026. Processing queues add another source of uncertainty. ED reported 86,520 PSLF Buyback applications pending at the end of January 2026. At January’s processing pace, clearing that backlog would take about three years. Scheeren’s third application has already waited nearly four years without a decision.

Buyback and standard PSLF applications are separate processes, but the delays create the same practical problem: borrowers can’t plan around forgiveness when their applications or payment counts remain unresolved.

What Happens Next

Judge Christopher Cooper must decide whether ED followed its own PSLF employer rules. Scheeren’s proposed order (PDF File) asks him to overturn the denials and declare the Fairfax Bar Association a qualifying employer. It would give ED 30 days to process forgiveness, with the discharge effective as of November 2021.

DOJ has offered to pause the case while ED reviews additional documents. Scheeren has asked the court to reject that proposal. The College Investor is also tracking court filings about student loan processing delays for signs that ED is clearing older PSLF forms.

Source: Robert Farrington · thecollegeinvestor.com