Anthropic Could Be the Next Amazon, and That’s the Problem
Anthropic may become one of the defining technology companies of this century. That still doesn’t make its stock a good buy at any price. With a rumored IPO valuation of $1.5 trillion to $2 trillion, even extraordinary success could leave investors with modest returns. That’s the risk investors should focus on.
Eric Fry, editor of Fry’s Investment Report, makes that case through a lesson from the dot-com boom: choosing the right company isn’t enough if you pay too much for it.

Roulette offers a useful analogy. A single-number bet pays 35 to 1 if the ball lands on your number, but American roulette also has green “0” and “00” slots that give the house an edge. Mario Puzo, the novelist behind The Godfather, put it bluntly: “If you are looking to cheat the house or beat it legitimately, forget about roulette. It’s basically a sucker’s game.”
Wall Street is preparing for a much larger wager. Anthropic, the company behind Claude, is expected to go public next month, with bankers reportedly discussing a valuation around $1.5 trillion and some estimates reaching $2 trillion. At that price, it would rank among the world’s most valuable companies from its first day of trading. The scale of the bet is striking; the uncertainty is just as large.
The dot-com record offers a caution. In a December 2000 study, three Wharton professors reviewed 48 publicly traded e-commerce companies that had attracted investors during the boom. Six had filed for bankruptcy, 15 traded below $1, Amazon had fallen 90% from its peak, and only 1-800-Contacts traded above its IPO price. A separate Wharton analysis estimated that around 1,100 sizable e-commerce businesses had operated during the bubble. By 2015, about 20 remained; Amazon and eBay had come to dominate the sector.
The internet did transform the economy. Most companies that pursued the opportunity still failed. That’s the point worth carrying into the AI boom: a technology can change everything while many investors lose money backing its supposed winners.
What the Amazon comparison leaves out
Anthropic isn’t Pets.com. Its revenue reached $16.8 billion in the third quarter, up from almost nothing two years earlier, and the company has a real chance to become a leading technology business. But strong growth alone can’t answer the investment question. Price matters.
Amazon’s market value at its December 1999 peak was about $36 billion in today’s dollars. That’s roughly comparable to Dassault Systèmes or Okta. Someone who bought Amazon at that peak still had room for an eventual 80-fold return as the company grew to a market value near $3 trillion.
Anthropic’s rumored price changes the arithmetic. At $1.5 trillion to $2 trillion, an 80-fold gain would imply a value of $120 trillion to $160 trillion. The upper end would be twice the value of the entire U.S. stock market today, twice the value of all U.S. real estate, and more than the combined net worth of American households. Those comparisons don’t prove Anthropic can’t justify its price, but they show how much future success investors may already be paying for.
That’s why “the next Amazon” isn’t a complete argument. A company can thrive and its shareholders can still be disappointed if they buy at a valuation that leaves little room for anything short of spectacular results.
Where the AI opportunity may lie
Fry’s lesson from the dot-com era isn’t to avoid technology. It’s to look beyond the most crowded bets and ask whether the price leaves room for error. He says he warned readers about Corning in Barron’s in 2000; within a year, the stock had dropped 87%. He instead recommended Humana, which was using the internet to make its existing business more efficient. That recommendation eventually gained more than 4,000%, he says.
He applies a similar distinction to AI, dividing companies into “AI Builders,” which spend heavily to develop models and infrastructure, and “AI Appliers,” established businesses using AI to cut costs, raise productivity, and improve profits. Builders could become highly successful, but a high starting valuation can limit investor returns. Some Appliers, Fry argues, may still trade at prices that allow for a more ordinary path to success.
Fry calls this divide the AI Separation and predicts it will begin on November 4, the morning after the midterms, weeks before Anthropic’s shares start trading. He offers a free presentation about the companies he believes will be affected and the first AI Applier he’d buy; the presentation is available here.
Anthropic could become a great company. The harder question is whether a $1.5 trillion to $2 trillion entry price leaves investors enough upside to justify the risk. Puzo’s roulette warning still fits: sometimes the better decision is to choose another game.
Entities and links retained: Eric Fry; Claude; Anthropic; Mario Puzo; The Godfather; Wharton School; 1-800-Contacts; Amazon (AMZN: ticker page); eBay (EBAY: ticker page); Dassault Systèmes (DASTY: ticker page); Okta (OKTA: ticker page); Corning (GLW: ticker page); Humana (HUM: ticker page); InvestorPlace technology sector page (link); Smart Money page (link); Eric Fry profile (link). Feature image source: Daniel Fung / Shutterstock. The original image link is here.
About the analyst
Eric Fry, editor of Smart Money, focuses on broad market trends that can drive multiyear moves across entire sectors. His approach is to look for opportunities that Wall Street regulars may overlook.
Printed from InvestorPlace Media: https://investorplace.com/smartmoney/2026/10/anthropic-could-be-the-next-amazon-and-thats-the-problem/. ©2026 InvestorPlace Media, LLC.