Banking

Federal Student Aid Independence Report Faces Legal and Staffing Hurdles

Oct 16, 2026 • 5 min read • views
New Department of Education Building Washington DC. Photo Credit: Robert Farrington

The reported plan to make Federal Student Aid an independent agency by Oct. 1, 2027, runs into two immediate constraints: federal law places FSA within the Education Department, and the office is operating with a much smaller workforce. The Washington Sun reported, citing three sources and internal documents, that FSA chief operating officer Richard Lucas is leading the effort with the White House Office of Management and Budget.

The Education Department disputes the account. Spokesperson Ellen Keast called it “fake news” and said the department is working to restore FSA as a performance-based organization. OMB described the reporting as “inaccurate” but offered no further detail. For borrowers, the report hasn’t changed current loan terms or servicing arrangements, including for people leaving the SAVE forbearance.

Congress would have to change the law

The law establishing FSA as a performance-based organization places it under the Education secretary. A standalone agency would therefore require an act of Congress. The Sun reported that the department has recognized this requirement internally, but has not approached lawmakers.

The operational stakes are considerable. FSA manages $1.6 trillion in student debt for 45 million borrowers and distributes $120 billion in loans and grants annually. Its workforce has fallen to 800 employees, down 43% since President Trump took office. The department’s inspector general has found that staff reductions weakened student loan oversight.

That capacity question complicates any timeline for a major reorganization. Melanie Storey, president and CEO of the National Association of Student Financial Aid Administrators and a former FSA policy implementation official, told the Sun that an October 2027 target seemed unrealistic given the work involved.

NASFAA has reported that 60% of college financial aid offices experienced slower federal processing after the workforce cuts. Three former Education secretaries have also asked the inspector general to examine the costs of the layoffs. FSA had roughly 1,440 full-time employees before the cuts and was pushed to try to rehire about 380 workers this spring. Education Secretary Linda McMahon has acknowledged that the reductions went too far.

Reorganization adds to existing changes

The reported proposal would extend an 18-month effort to shift work from the Education Department. In March 2025, Trump said the Small Business Administration “will handle all of the student loan portfolio.” No formal transfer followed; federal student loans remained with the Education Department under the Higher Education Act.

Instead, the department has used agreements with other agencies. In November 2025, it moved most Higher Education Act grant programs to the Labor Department, while retaining oversight. A March 2026 agreement gave Treasury control of defaulted loan collections. That effort is planned in three phases and could expand to the broader loan portfolio and FAFSA.

Those transfers have drawn objections. In April 2026, five Senate Democrats called the Treasury arrangement an “illegal scheme”, arguing that the 2026 spending law prevents the department from transferring its statutory responsibilities.

Borrower advocates have also questioned whether changing FSA’s structure would address repayment pressures. Protect Borrowers Executive Director Mike Pierce said changing the agency’s name would not lower costs for working-class families. The group says more than 3 million borrowers defaulted last year, with another 3 million on track to default this year. American Federation of Teachers President Randi Weingarten said a reorganization “will only make things worse,” citing the union’s lawsuit over income-driven repayment.

What the report means for borrowers

The Education Department and OMB are reportedly scheduled to discuss the proposal next week. A formal request to Congress would be a key development: House Republicans have already proposed bills to dismantle the department, but an independent FSA would still need statutory authorization.

A change in the department’s name is another possibility. Congress created the Education Department by statute, so a rebrand alone would not alter the law governing student loans. For borrowers, the reported plans do not change balances, payments or servicing today. The practical signal to watch is whether lawmakers receive a formal proposal—and whether FSA can maintain service levels as its structure and staffing remain in flux.

Source: Robert Farrington · thecollegeinvestor.com