A diversified mix of value, momentum and quality delivered a higher information ratio than any of its individual factor sleeves in a long US equity backtest. The result points to a practical feature of multifactor investing: diversification can matter at several levels, from the signals used to define a factor to the factors combined in a portfolio. The timing overlay in the study had a smaller role, adding little over the full sample.
Anthony Renshaw, Yurong Gu, Matt Candar and Andrew Ang examine that approach in their July 2026 paper, “Diversification all the Way Down: Multifactor Investing Within Factors, Across Factors and Across Time.” Their framework combines multiple signals within factors, balances several factors against one another, and uses an ensemble of timing models to make bounded adjustments to factor weights.
Building diversification into the portfolio
The study’s US portfolio combines four sleeves: cyclical value, enhanced value, momentum and quality. Its benchmark is the STOXX US Universal Index. The backtest runs from 2004 through May 2026, with quarterly rebalancing, a 1% ex ante tracking-error target and a 5% cap on quarterly one-way turnover. Concentration and industry constraints help keep the portfolio benchmark-aware.
Value is split into two distinct approaches. Cyclical value uses familiar valuation ratios, including book-to-price and earnings yield. Enhanced value draws on economic profit, intangible capital and free cash flow. The distinction matters because the measures can behave differently: classic valuation ratios may capture a different set of companies and exposures than measures that account for profit generation and less tangible assets.

Momentum also extends beyond price trends. The authors combine idiosyncratic momentum, short interest, hedge fund positioning, analyst revisions and economic-profit momentum. The aim is to avoid letting one momentum measure drive the sleeve’s results.


For quality, the study uses the Axioma US5.1 Profit Quality factor, which brings together profitability, cash-flow strength, operating efficiency and accruals. The four sleeves receive balanced weights, while portfolio constraints keep beta and tracking error within the strategy’s design. The intent is to let distinct sources of factor return contribute without allowing one style to set the portfolio’s character.
Size and low volatility are left out. According to the paper, their beta profiles would have made it harder to stay within the tracking-error budget: small stocks tend to have betas above 1, while low-volatility stocks tend to have betas below 1.
What the backtest shows
Enhanced value and cyclical value produced meaningfully different exposures. The authors report that enhanced value was more resilient during extended periods when traditional value struggled. That finding supports treating valuation ratios and measures linked to intangible assets and economic profit as complementary inputs, rather than interchangeable definitions of cheapness.

The combined portfolio’s full-sample information ratio was 1.00. Enhanced value recorded 0.94, quality 0.73 and momentum 0.65; cyclical value came in at -0.20. The information ratio compares active return with the volatility of that return relative to a benchmark. On this measure, the portfolio that combined the sleeves performed better than each one on its own.
Weak correlations among the factor sleeves help explain the result. When one sleeve lagged, another could contribute differently; the portfolio’s outcome depended less on any single style’s run. That pattern also explains why a factor that looks weakest over one period may lead in another. The study presents rotating leadership as a reason to diversify exposures, rather than as a reliable signal that one factor will remain out of favor.

Timing played a supporting role
The researchers also tested an overlay that averages bounded tilts from three timing models built on different information sets. Each model can double or halve a factor’s nominal weight, but cannot remove the factor altogether. This structure limits the effect of any one model and keeps the portfolio anchored to its diversified mix.
Timing improved performance over the most recent three-year period covered by the analysis, but added little over the entire backtest. That makes the overlay a secondary element in the findings. The larger contribution came from combining factors with weak correlations; the evidence for timing was more dependent on the period examined.

What the results mean for portfolio design
The paper’s central point is that diversification can be applied repeatedly. Multiple measures can inform each factor, several factors can be combined, and any timing adjustments can be spread across models and kept within limits. Each layer reduces dependence on a single estimate or market environment, though the backtest itself doesn’t establish that the same performance will persist in other periods.
For value exposure, the split between cyclical and enhanced measures is especially relevant. A portfolio based only on traditional ratios may miss signals tied to cash generation, economic profit or intangible capital. The study’s results suggest those approaches can behave differently, making a combined definition a broader way to express the value style.
The timing results call for restraint. The overlay’s recent-period improvement did not translate into a meaningful full-sample contribution, so the paper gives limited support for making tactical forecasts the main driver of a multifactor strategy. As Cliff Asness puts it in his discussion of “sin a little,” modest tilts can sit alongside a diversified core. Here, the evidence supports that as a limited enhancement, not as a replacement for exposure across styles.
My read is that the study’s most useful result is the relative contribution of the diversified core: the combined strategy’s information ratio exceeded those of all four sleeves over the stated sample, while timing added little over the full period. Portfolio design, in this case, relied more on spreading exposure across signals and factors than on identifying the next leading style.
Larry Swedroe is the author or co-author of 18 books on investing, including his latest Enrich Your Future. He is also a consultant to RIAs as an educator on investment strategies. He has spent decades helping advisors and investors apply the evidence from academic finance to real-world portfolios. This article is for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as specific investment, accounting, legal, or tax advice.
Diversification All the Way Down was originally published at Alpha Architect. Please read the Alpha Architect disclosures at your convenience.