Investing

Swiss Study Finds Complex Retail Products Carry Higher Markups and Lower Returns

Oct 05, 2026 • 5 min read • views

Complexity can protect an issuer’s margins by making competing products harder to compare. Evidence from Switzerland’s market for yield enhancement products suggests that this effect matters for retail investors: as competition intensified, issuers sold more multi-asset products, which carried higher markups and produced lower realized returns than simpler alternatives.

That finding complicates the usual story of product innovation. New structures can serve real investment needs, but complexity may also help distinguish one product from another in ways that frustrate price comparison. When buyers struggle to judge whether two offerings are economically alike, competition has less room to push their prices down.

Product design and competition

The study, “Competition, complexity, and security design: evidence from retail investment products,” examines barrier reverse convertibles in Switzerland. The paper is by Marc Chesney, Felix Fattinger, Jonathan Krakow and Simon Straumann, and appeared in the Review of Finance in 2026. A version is available here.

The authors compare products linked to one underlying asset, which they call Singles, with products linked to several assets, or Multis. Multis allow issuers to combine different securities and terms, creating a wider range of possible offerings. That variety can make it harder for investors to identify close substitutes and compare prices directly.

As competition increased, issuers shifted toward Multis. The authors interpret this pattern as evidence consistent with strategic product design: complexity can differentiate an offering and weaken the pressure to match a rival’s terms. The results do not establish that every complex product is designed for that purpose. They do suggest that investor demand and financial innovation alone may not explain the growth in complexity.

Higher markups, weaker realized returns

The cost differences reported in the paper are material. Annualized markups on Multis are about 4 percentage points higher than on Singles. Realized returns are approximately 2.1 percentage points lower for Multis. Average excess returns are negative for both types, with substantially worse results for the multi-asset products.

The competitive effect also differs by product type. Markups on Singles decline as competition increases, while markups on Multis remain high. That gap fits the authors’ account: straightforward products are easier to line up against alternatives, so competition can more directly constrain their pricing. A broader menu of possible combinations makes that comparison harder for Multis.

For investors, a headline coupon or payoff feature doesn’t capture the full economics. The relevant question is what the product costs and what outcomes its structure makes possible. Two offerings with similar advertised terms can still differ in markup, downside exposure and realized performance.

Comparable products put pressure on pricing

The researchers examine “twin products”: offerings issued around the same time with the same underlying assets and maturities. These twins give investors a more direct basis for comparison. When a Multi has a comparable alternative, its terms are better and its markup is lower, according to the study.

But such comparisons are less common for Multis. Only 29% have a preceding twin product, compared with 68% of Singles. The difference matters because a product that lacks a close benchmark is harder to price against a competing offer. The evidence therefore points to comparability as an economic force in its own right: when alternatives are easier to match, issuers face more pressure to compete on terms.

That doesn’t mean a twin is a perfect substitute or that comparing two products resolves every valuation question. It does mean that a lack of close alternatives should make product evaluation more demanding. Investors and advisers need to establish what the payoff depends on, how the terms compare and what the issuer’s markup implies for expected outcomes.

Investors may misread multi-asset risk

A laboratory experiment offers one explanation for why investors may accept the terms of more complex products. Participants estimated the probability of a barrier event accurately for simple products. For Multis, they underestimated that probability by about 6.2 percentage points and valued the products more highly relative to fair value. The misjudgment was larger among participants with greater overconfidence.

The results point to a specific challenge: assessing how several assets interact in a worst-of payoff. When the outcome depends on the weakest-performing underlying asset, adding more securities doesn’t necessarily spread risk in the way a diversified portfolio might. More assets can mean more chances that at least one performs poorly enough to affect the payoff. The structure, rather than the number of names alone, determines the exposure.

This is where complexity becomes more than a pricing issue. If investors underestimate the chance of crossing a barrier, they may accept risks that aren’t adequately reflected in the product’s terms. The paper characterizes the resulting exposure as uncompensated risk-taking, with greater concern for less sophisticated investors.

Who benefits from easier comparisons?

The study also finds differences among investors. Those holding competitively priced simple products tend to be wealthier and hold more diversified portfolios. Their portfolios also show better returns, Sharpe ratios and alpha. These associations don’t prove that product choice alone caused the performance differences. They do support the authors’ concern that investors with fewer resources or less financial sophistication may be more exposed to complex offerings.

The broader market implication is uneven competition. Investors who can identify and compare simpler products may benefit when issuers compete directly on price. Others may face products that are more difficult to evaluate and carry higher markups. In that setting, market competition can improve terms for some buyers without exerting the same pressure across the full retail market.

What to examine in a structured product

For investment professionals reviewing these products, the study’s practical message is to examine the economic exposure behind the headline terms. That includes the full payoff distribution, the issuer markup and the role of downside risk. A prominent coupon describes one feature; it doesn’t by itself show whether the expected return compensates for the risks embedded in the structure.

For a worst-of product, focus on how the weakest underlying asset affects the outcome and how adding assets changes the chance of an adverse event. Then look for comparable products with the same underlying assets and maturity. If close alternatives are scarce, that makes the price harder to assess and strengthens the case for a careful comparison of terms and risks.

The authors’ findings don’t make every Multi unattractive or every Single fairly priced. They do show why product complexity deserves scrutiny: it can make comparison harder just where clearer comparisons would give buyers more bargaining power. In this market, understanding the structure and finding a credible benchmark are central to judging what the investor is paying for.

Study details and chart

The source article identifies the following table as showing regressions on the likelihood of a relationship between a prospective adviser and client, measured against their social distance. It describes each observation as a client–adviser combination. That description does not match the paper’s discussion of Swiss retail investment products, so the chart’s relevance to the study’s findings is unclear.

The results are hypothetical results and are NOT an indicator of future results and do NOT represent returns that any investor actually attained. Indexes are unmanaged and do not reflect management or trading fees, and one cannot invest directly in an index.

The paper’s abstract describes its central finding as evidence consistent with issuers increasing complexity to mitigate price competition. It says complex designs make products harder to compare, carry higher markups and tail risk, and are first-order stochastically dominated by simpler products. The authors conclude that rising market complexity increases uncompensated risk-taking, particularly among less sophisticated investors, and can preserve issuer rents.

For more academic finance paper summaries, see Alpha Architect’s Academic Research Insight category. The original article, Buying Complex Retail Investment Products May Not be a Great Idea, was published at Alpha Architect. Read the publisher’s disclosures.

Source: Elisabetta Basilico, PhD, CFA · alphaarchitect.com