Student debt appears to constrain retirement saving at several points: borrowers enroll in workplace plans less often, contribute a smaller share of pay and build lower balances. The gap is widest in borrowers’ 40s, when median 401(k) balances are about 45% below those of peers without student loans, according to research from the Employee Benefit Research Institute (EBRI).
That pattern gives employers a concrete reason to examine student loan matching. EBRI estimates that if all employers offered the feature, borrowers ages 25 to 69 would receive an additional $11.2 billion a year in employer contributions under a 4% match cap, or $20.2 billion under a 6% cap.
The report, Understanding Who Would Benefit From a Student Loan Retirement Matching Program and by How Much, compares anonymized TransUnion credit records with 401(k) plan data. Funded by student debt benefits platform Candidly, it is the first of two EBRI studies on the subject; that funding is relevant context for interpreting the findings.
Where the retirement savings gap appears
About one in five 401(k) participants ages 25 to 69 in the dataset had student loan debt. The share was highest among younger workers: 35.7% of participants ages 25 to 29 had loans, compared with 20.8% among those ages 40 to 44 and 12.9% among those ages 55 to 59.
Among eligible workers ages 25 to 34, 75.5% of borrowers enrolled in a defined contribution plan, versus 84.1% of workers without student debt. Borrowers also contributed less at every income level. The largest difference in median contribution rates was among participants ages 50 to 54, where borrowers’ rates were 14.7% lower.
Account balances were lower for borrowers across income and tenure groups. The largest reported gap was among people in their 40s: their median balances were roughly 45% below those of debt-free peers. Even older borrowers had balances about 30% lower, according to EBRI.
Contribution levels also point to forgone employer money. In the study, 39.2% of borrowers contributed less than 4% of pay, 49.7% contributed less than 5%, and 61.3% contributed less than 6%—levels that often fall below employer match caps. For borrowers contributing under their plan’s cap, the median employer contribution ranged from 60 to 70 cents per employee dollar.
How student loan matching works
Under the student loan matching option enabled by SECURE 2.0 in 2024, employers can count a qualified student loan payment toward the contribution needed to earn a 401(k) match. A borrower paying a loan instead of contributing to the retirement plan can therefore qualify for employer contributions, subject to the plan’s terms.
The potential scale is large, but adoption remains concentrated among large companies such as Boeing, Verizon and Comcast. EBRI’s estimates assume every employer adopts a program, so they show the possible contribution pool rather than a forecast of actual participation or employer spending.
Student loan balances remain substantial. EBRI cites $1.66 trillion outstanding in the first quarter of 2026, based on credit bureau data. A broader Federal Reserve consumer credit series puts the figure at $1.86 trillion in the second quarter of 2026. Both measures are more than four times the $360 billion reported in 2005.
What employers and borrowers can take from the findings
The results suggest the retirement savings effect of student debt may extend beyond the monthly loan payment. Lower enrollment and contributions can also mean less employer matching and fewer years for savings to compound. EBRI’s comparisons document an association between student debt and lower saving; they don’t establish that debt alone caused the differences.
For plan sponsors, the next key evidence will come from EBRI’s second study, which is expected to model how added matching contributions affect retirement income adequacy over a full career. That analysis may help employers assess the longer-term results alongside the estimated annual cost.
For borrowers, the immediate detail is their plan’s match threshold and whether loan payments qualify for matching. EBRI’s figures show how often borrowers contribute below common caps, while the projected reach of these programs will depend on how many employers choose to offer them.